Friday, December 12, 2025

Indiana Says No

     Indiana's where I live, and it's a pretty conservative place.  It's full of stubborn people, and if you want them to change how they do things -- anything -- you'd better be filling a genuine need.  Hamilton County's road system has more roundabouts than anywhere in the U.S., but it only happened after decades of explosive population growth and four-way-stop gridlock that made getting anywhere at rush hour a crawlingly slow and frustrating experience.

    Indiana, like many other GOP-dominated states, has been under pressure from the Trump administration to redraw U. S. House districts and help retain the GOP trifecta in Washington, DC in the 2026 general election.  We've got nine districts; all but two of them are easy wins for Republicans.  Those two -- Marion County/Indianapolis/Seventh District, and the Chicago-adjacent  First District -- are about as strongly Democratic.  The proposed map split the Democrat strongholds; Marion county got it worse than Caesar's Gaul, hacked between four districts that extended deep into rural areas, most running all the way to the state boundaries.

     This wasn't a secret effort; the intention was well known and the maps were published.  Indiana doesn't have any rules against partisan gerrymandering.  But it didn't sit well with voters.

     I think there were two main issues.  One was that the changes were sweeping.  Your old, familiar House district would be gone, possibly taking your old, familiar U. S. Congresscritter with it.  In central Indiana, there was concern that "four millionaires from Indianapolis" would be speaking for primarily agricultural, rural areas, whose concerns would be underrepresented.  And the move was petty: with the GOP holding seven of the nine districts, they've already got a commanding lead; two more wouldn't make a big difference.

     For all those reasons, and plenty more, our state Senate rejected the effort, 31 to 19.  There are fifty seats; Republicans hold forty of them, so it doesn't take a math whiz to work out that 21 of the No votes came from Republicans.  When you can't sell a majority of your own party's state Senators on it, maybe redrawing the Congressional map isn't such a great idea.

     The legislature doesn't get another bite at the apple until Spring, too late to redistrict ahead of the mid-term elections.

Thursday, December 11, 2025

Discontinuity

     Ever bend a hard plastic rod?  Many plastics will go quite a ways, and then, all of a sudden--  They break. 

     Mr. Trump's Republican party is courting chaos like a lovestruck teenager.

     In Missouri, both sides were playing chess -- until one side pulled out a baseball bat.  The legislature passed a bill to rearrange Federal House districts, with a map that will flip one of the two usually-Democratic districts in favor of Republicans.  Opponents fought back, with a ballot-initiative petition drive to put the new map up for a statewide vote.  You can do that in Missouri, but it takes a pile of signatures, and they've got to come from at least six of the state's eight House districts. 

     In fact, it takes a tick over 100,000 signatures.  The petitioners have collected well over 300,000, from all eight districts.  So it'll almost certainly go on the ballot, and per established precedent, the law is frozen once enough signatures have been turned in, while Missourians wait until it is determined if the signature requirements have officially been met, and until they've had a chance to vote on it if the number beat the minimum.

     The Republican Secretary of State says no; even if there are enough signatures, he can just declare the referendum unconstitutional all by himself.  And if so, the whole thing goes off the courts to work out.  It's not how the Show Me state has dealt with similar referenda in the past.  The power to shout, "Allee, allee, oxen-free," and dump the process has never been asserted by the Missouri Secretary of State before.  It seems, well, not the way a proper Republic goes about such things.  It's high-handed.  Authoritarian.

     In a state whose citizens are nationally famous for mulishness, it might not be the course of action that a sober, cautious politician should choose.

     I guess we'll find out.  Bending, bending--  Whattaya think?  Snap, or will it stay bent?  And what gets that treatment next?

     It feels like the lights are about to start going out, like the walls are closing in.  There's a lot of ruin in a big, well-established country, but there's no damn requirement to test that proposition to destruction.

Wednesday, December 10, 2025

Nostalgia In A Lab Coat

      Hey, remember when "consensus reality" and "objective reality" were pretty nearly congruent and widely shared?  Me too!  And now you can revisit those halcyon days with this handy list of ten things that are still true, despite fads and popular delusions!  (Many people will balk at #1 and yet -- there it is.)

Tuesday, December 09, 2025

Living In A Fantasy

      Indiana's diminutive Lieutenant Governor Micah Beckwith is at it again, this time with as fractured a historical analogy as you're ever likely to encounter: he says the Indiana Senate Republican holdouts against redistricting are "Neville Chamberlain types," attempting to "appease" Democrats.

     Precisely what state or Federal level Democrats have the power to do that merits appeasement is unclear; in Indiana, the GOP holds a commanding trifecta, and while their margins at the Federal level are far narrower, they've got majorities in the House and Senate and, of course, are firmly ensconced in the two-thirds of the White House still standing.  The Dems are nowhere near positioning to take the Sudetenland and the GOP hasn't sat down with them for a Munich Conference. 

     The John Birchers of my youth had a clearer grasp of history than young Beckwith (despite their spin), and their most fevered fantasies fell far short of the notions he so confidently spews.  He's all over the more-unmoored parts of the online Right chat-show circuit, a self-identified Christian Nationalist with, apparently, plenty of free time.

     Indiana's Governor, Mike Braun, comes across as a gruff paterfamilias type; he's absolutely on board with President Trump's agenda, 110%, but does so in a low-drama way, focused on the nuts and bolts of politics.  I think his number two, not the Governor's own choice, shows a decided preference for the nuts alone.

Monday, December 08, 2025

Indiana Redistricting

     Indiana's in the middle of a redistricting fight.  The measure passed the House 57-41; not coincidentally, Indiana's Presidential votes typically run near a 60/40 split.*

     The state Senate vote will probably begin in the Elections Committee today and it's looking interesting, with a 3-3-3 split, pro, con and undecided.  If the bill reaches the floor, the GOP needs 26 votes to pass; they hold 40 of the 50 seats -- but 14 Republican Senators say they're against the measure.

     Five Republican Senators aren't saying where they stand.  The bill has a lot of moving parts besides the new map, among them language meant to control how and in what courts suits challenging the legislation may be filed, complexity that gives Senators room to say they're still studying

     Twelve legislators, most of them Republicans, have publicly stated they have had swatting attempts, bomb threats and so on over this bill.  Meanwhile, President Trump has called out nine Indiana state Senators by name, telling supporters, "Let your voice be heard loud and clear."  You can parse that however you like; in context, the statement allows Eddie Haskell levels of ambiguity.

     Local advertising, on TV, and via direct mail, email and text messages, has been intense, mostly warning me about the terrible, terrible things the Democrats are going to do if they retake control of the House in 2026.  The list includes everything from bumper sticker level fantasy about the horrors of wokeness to threatening exactly what I'd like to see: a series of impeachments, convictions and removals from office.  Based on past performance, none of them are things the Dems are really likely to do, and more's the pity.  But it's keeping the lights on at the TV stations and penny-rate electronic and bulk-mail companies, so thanks for that, and for the ongoing, mortifying soap opera that is the collapse of the American system of government.  Mr. Putin and Mr. Xi must be so happy about that last item, and isn't happiness what it's really all about?
____________________

* You'd think, in a polity of sturdy, politically-active Jeffersonian yoemen (and woemen), this would point to a 60/40 split in our U.S. House delegation.  Perish the thought, say redistricting proponents; they're aiming for a nice 60/40 division in each and every district, sending a winner-take-all wall of House Republicans off to Washington DC and the 40% will just have to take their lumps.

Sunday, December 07, 2025

Subjective Reality

     Watching the Sunday morning political shows was an especially pointed example of "One screen, two movies."

     Especially when it came to the issue of military response to alleged drug-runners at sea.  Such facts as both sides agree on are sketchy at best: a fast, small boat, almost certainly a smuggler and very likely running drugs,* destination unknown, was fired on by U.S, forces are badly damaged.  When the smoke cleared, some portion of the vessel remained afloat, either the overturned hull or a large piece of it.  On that floating object were two individuals, moving around in a purposeful manner.  One of them removed his shirt.  After some time had passed, the U.S. forced stuck again, obliterating the people and whatever they were floating on.  And there's video if it.

     Several members of the United States Congress have seen that video, and their reports disagree significantly.  Some (mostly Democrats) saw two survivors, possibly trying to right the vessel or portion of a vessel, possibly trying to signal for help by gesturing.  Others (mostly Republicans) saw two individuals, trying to right the vessel, recover the cargo, and radio for assistance from other smugglers.

     They all saw the same video, probably on a large screen, probably in as high a resolution as authorized  Department of Defense personnel saw it when it was happening in real time.  And they took away different narratives.

     Stepping back, on the one hand, we have a small, fast, heavily-laden vessel, not as large as a WW II PT boat, with powerful engines and armed with rifles at best.  On the other, we have good-sized ships of the U. S. Navy; the outcome of battle between them is not in doubt.

     Is it appropriate or legal for a nation's Navy to fire on smuggling vessels in the open sea?

     Having done so, is it appropriate or legal for a nation's Navy to fire on any crew of that vessel who survived the initial attack?

     It is well established that vessels suspected of unlawful activity can be "pulled over" -- commanded to heave to, with a shot over the bows if they don't comply, illegal freight seized, crew arrested.  It is well established that if a small (or large) vessel makes aggressive moves towards a Navy ship -- say, a shipload of Houthi militants with an eye on eternity -- shots across the bow can become shots on target.  It is eminently lawful under international agreements to resist and hunt down pirates.

     There's no precedent for hunting down dope-runners and blowing them out of the water.  There's precedent against killing survivors after an attack.  When German and Imperial Japanese naval vessels did so to Allied crews in wartime, they were reviled for it.

     DoD may release the video.  We're not going to get the same resolution their guys saw.  We're not going to get the same image quality elected politicians saw, and there's good reason for that: DoD doesn't want any foe to know just how well they can be seen.  But if we get to see it, whatever we get, from fuzzy proxies to 720p, we're going to look at the same screen and see two films.

     History will only see one.  I wonder which it will be?
_______________________
* The administration keeps saying it's fentanyl.  Experts say it's most likely cocaine, and not headed directly to the U.S.  It's very likely drugs, though even that is not certain.  It is smuggling of some kind. 

Saturday, December 06, 2025

History Grinds On

     It's painful to watch: some of my friends and former friends, lifelong Republicans, or conservatives, or l/Libertarians, are starting to wonder if they might have some very unsavory bedfellows, as the Trump administration departs farther and farther from norms of civilized, decent behavior and the rule of law.

     They're in an awkward position, among their own friends, many of whom are very much on board with wherever the current version of the GOP is headed; others are suppressing their own doubts, struggling to come up with reasons why the Democrats could only be worse, or why no moderate or even traditional Republican should try sailing into the blowhard winds coming from the White House.

     Some of them may bail out, eventually, and at no small short-term personal cost; ask Liz Cheney.  Others will ride it all the way down until it augers in, as it inevitably must, "good Germans," patriots who "had no idea what all was going on."

     The perpetrators will some day come to justice, or at least flee from it, by death or jet plane, red-handed and reviled, but the people who stood idly by and let it happen, the cheering throngs who never looked too closely, the passive fellow-travelers who figured it would all blow over if they looked the other way, they'll all get a pass, just like always.

     We're going to be stuck with the hard work of rebuilding a society that values science and sanity, that believes in the inherent worth of people, that all men -- and all women -- are equal before the law, and many of our fellows will still be drifting along with the current, ignoring that scintilla of guilt sizzling away in the back of their minds: they could have been against the current mess sooner; they could have helped nip it in the bud.  They didn't, and the blood is already on everyone's hands.

     There will come a day when they shake their heads sadly, and mutter, "We didn't know.  We couldn't have stopped it."  What they'll mean is, "We didn't want to know.  It was too much effort to stop it," but history says we'll let them hang on to their self-protecting illusions, and work to do better next time.

     The march of human progress is not a smooth, simple upward curve.  It never has been.

Friday, December 05, 2025

Aghast At Dinner?

     A recipe popped up on my New Page screen that gave me pause.  I don't know; maybe it's delicious.  Maybe it's just calling it "pizza beans skillet" that strikes me oddly, for all that I love beans, pizza, and things made with tomato sauce and plenty of spices.

     Maybe I'd just rather wonder about thinner-than-usual pizza sauce, the Usual Ingredients,* cooked cannellini beans and a nice cheese topping than about the state of politics.  It's certainly a lot nicer to look over at the other guy's plate -- and see that he has a plate, and dinner on it -- and think, "That looks great," or, "Oh, no thanks," instead of you both thinking, "That weirdo needs to leave."
_______________________
* But not pineapple.

Thursday, December 04, 2025

Beneath Contempt

     Move over, Andrew Jackson!  Scoot down, Woodrow Wilson!  Man, the kind of talk coming out of the White House these days would have gotten a guy shushed at a John Bircher meeting, once upon a time.

     This once was -- and not so long ago -- a country where we'd let people fail on their own lack of merits, as individuals, and figure it was that one guy, or maybe him and his criminal associates, not every person who came from the same place.  It was a country where even a man inclined to wave a broad brush at entire groups of people -- like my Dad, along about the late 1960s, with his first few African-American electronic-production workers in the "clean room," training them reluctantly and pleasantly surprised that they were just as good as their predecessor peers.  A few trainees would wash out every hiring cycle and it was no different that time around, but lo, the skills needed for that job turned out to have nothing to do with the complexion of the workers.

     A President who fumes, "Everybody from [foreign nation] is garbage.  They're ruining this country," is talking racist nonsense.  Look, there are people who are harsh judges of character and people who are lenient; that's one thing.  But making sweeping claims about demographic groups is bullshit.  It's flatly wrong -- and so is anyone who overlooks such behavior, no matter what their reason might be.  (Video here -- and my quotes are approximate.)

     We're all equal before the law.  That's the notion this country was founded on and has struggled to live up to.  Presidents ought not try to drown the idea in a ditch.  It's unworthy of the office.

Wednesday, December 03, 2025

Maybe It's Not Just Disliking The Cold

     Yesterday, I had sinuses so messed up that I wasn't navigating well.  After a couple of attempts to get out of the house, I gave up, got out the nasal lavage supplies, and managed to reach a state of only mild headache and nearly free breathing without having to gulp like a carp, but so weak I could have been beaten up by a squirrel.

     Today opened with a knitting-needles-in-the-ears headache plus sinus pain; I took acetaminophen and crawled back into bed for a couple of hours.

     The sudden onslaught of winter filled me with dread, but I thought that was just emotional silliness, the kind of thing you rub a little dirt into and keep moving.  Maybe not.  Dammit.

Tuesday, December 02, 2025

Flashback?

     Fox News is in court again -- well, still -- facing off against a voting-machine company.  What, you thought it was over, and that they'd settled out of court for a staggering sum?

     That was Dominion.  This is Smartmatic, and it ain't over yet.  Lawyers and PR flacks from both sides are talking tough and the shockingly cynical comments from Fox on-air talent and others that came out in the run-up to the Dominion settlement are getting another run-though.

     Will Fox blink?  Will Smartmatic prevail if the case goes to trial?  I don't know.  I do know it's all about eyeballs and the relentless pursuit of them -- and the ad dollars they bring -- by Fox News.  If you were expecting any Edward R. Murrow-like pronouncements of journalistic ideals, or even partisan flag-waving like the newspaper magnates of old, forget it.

Monday, December 01, 2025

Rankings

     GDP -- Gross Domestic Product -- is an imperfect measure of how well a country is doing.  You can't look at it and infer, for instance, how comfortably plumbers in Beijing, Vladivostok, Kokomo and Kerala are living relative to one another.

     But it's what we've got, an apples-to-apples yardstick that tells us a little about the average wage-earner and a lot about countries as a whole.

     By that yardstick, the U.S.is way out in front, with China and the EU  jostling for a fair second place.  The rest of the world is a lot worse off -- Russia is down between Canada and Italy, with an economy thirteen percent the size of the EU or China, eight percent that of the U.S.  Call it 2.5 trillion dollars.  California's most recent GDP numbers, over four trillion, put it well ahead of the sprawling giant.  If California were a country, they'd rank about fourth (and they'd be spending a lot more on defense, so don't get too complacent out there).  Gavin Newsom is running a larger country than Vladimir Putin, despite having a fraction of the land area and less than a third of the population.

     When you see Russia referred to as a "paper tiger," that's the kind of thing they mean.  The butter is spread very thin over there -- and thinner still, given what Mr. Putin's government is spending on guns instead.  That's a big slice of the planet, and a big chunk of the world's population, on short rations and fighting what amounts to World War One with added robot bombs.

     China is gleefully watching Mr. Trump run America's share of Western Civilization down the garbage disposal, thinking they'll end up on top.  It's a lot more likely they'll go down the drain along with us, if it comes to that; based on past performance, their response to a global war or the next pandemic is likely to come up short.

     With the rise in preventable disease, trade wars, regular wars, growing disregard for the rule of law, devaluation of science and increase in illusory BS (much of it driven by AI), humanity seems determined to dig themselves into a new Dark Ages.  While there's evidence they're not quite as "dark" as popular opinion believes (nor the collapse as sudden), it's not a bright time, and as a species, we're not too bright if we fall into it because we've decided we don't like our neighbors and that tolerating harmless weirdos is too much work.

     The hopeful side -- and the scary side -- is that the United States is an 800-pound gorilla, the only one on the planet.  When the U.S. has a cold, there's sneezing all around the world.  And we've got our act together, we tend to pull everyone else along.

     The barbarians are at the gates -- and a lot of them are coming from inside the walls, where they've been all their lives.